25 April 2009

Supermarkets Selling Mobility and Daily Living Aids

Two major supermarkets, Asda and the Co-op, have both recently launched into the sale of mobility and daily living aids. The attractions for them are quite clear - we all know about the demographic shift which is growing this market as longevity increases and the post-war baby boomers become pensioners, demanding an increasing range of products to help maintain independence and quality of life.

Having already diversified successfully from their core food lines, where competition is fierce and margins narrow, into areas such as fashion, electronics and homewares, the supermarkets are keen to repeat the trick, using their strong branding and purchasing power to develop new and profitable ranges. Which in some ways is fine - as consumers we have certainly benefitted from the might of the big retailers driving down the cost of our weekly shop and increasing the variety of goods we can conveniently buy under one roof.

There are some daily living aids which fit perfectly well into the supermarket model, such as easy grip utensils, big button phones and remote controls, bath rails and non-slip mats - but I really think we need to ask the question: should walking aids, for example, be regarded as just another product to pick off the shelf along with the washing powder and coffee? Given that somebody who is looking to buy a walking frame necessarily has difficulties walking, and that choosing the wrong one could cause them additional problems, should we not be ensuring that they can talk to someone who is well-trained in assessing such needs and recommending a suitable solution, rather than leaving them to take whatever their local supermarket has decided to stock?

Co-op Xest, the website and catalogue via which the Co-op is selling their range, does not include wheelchairs: interviewed by the BBC, their spokesperson said: “... we are not selling wheelchairs and we have just under 1000 products, but wheelchairs are not amongst them because of the specialist advice that you need.”

Asda, on the other hand, appears to have no such qualms - visitors to the 75 stores piloting the sale of mobility products will be able to buy a wheelchair for significantly less than £100. Their spokesperson indicated that giving specialist advice would not be a problem as he expected their customers would obtain the necessary information from the NHS before purchasing from them. An interesting idea, but one that doesn't really stand up to close scrutiny. Will checkout staff be asking buyers whether they obtained appropriate advice before going to the supermarket? And how will they know whether the product they have selected accords with that advice?

This is just the latest example of major mainstream brands rushing to grab their slice of the apparently lucrative special needs market: we have already seen it with bed and easychair suppliers and bathroom manufacturers. You can certainly argue that the increased competition has done wonders for aesthetics: today's mobility and daily living aids bear no resemblance to the ugly functionality of a decade or so ago. But the cost has been an increase in inappropriate selling techniques, with vulnerable people spending significant amounts on products that are unsuitable for them, because the supplier is more concerned with making a sale than meeting the user's needs.

Having spent twenty years in this business; ten of them editing the Independent Living website, advising people always to make sure that they try a range of mobility products - ideally in an impartial environment such as a Disabled Living Centre - before buying, I am more than a little concerned at the involvement of the supermarkets. Selling mobility aids is about more than simply shifting boxes, and I think we all need to give this new development some careful thought, rather than sleepwalking into a situation where giant retail chains become the 100lb gorilla in this special market.

7 comments:

  1. Disability aids SHOULD not be purchased from Supermarkets. The information required for a person to
    purchase the correct aid for them is
    specific. If the wrong aid is purchased because the price is lower
    the person could make their condition
    worse. A walking stick needs to be the correct length, weight, and grip.
    There are so many that look pretty but do they do their job properly, they are not just something to hold on to.
    I feel very strongly that supermarkets should sell food and
    home wares, not disability aids. They should leave that to the professionals who know what they are doing!!! By all means find out the right equipment for you and the best place to buy it from,
    who can give you after care and are reliable. Sorry, I have jumped
    on my soap box!!
    ReplyDelete
  2. In my area we still get these types of small aids free when recommended by the Social Services Occupational Therapist so I shouldn't think there is much call for them to be stocked in my area.

    Argos and other catalogues have been selling mobility aids for quite some time.

    If it keeps prices down for those who would normally have to pay then that's a good thing, so long as there has been some professional advice beforehand, but, some aids are positively dangerous if unsuitable for particular people and it is a concern that people can buy things that a) may make things worse b) may cost them money when they could possibly get them free c) there may be a more suitable aid available which is not in the supermarket, which OT's keep constantly up to date with.
    ReplyDelete
  3. I would of thought that if the supermarkets can sell at a lower price including VAT than the disability equipment shops do without VAT, its a good thing. After all, the mark up on most equipment and its RRP are scandalously high. hence the fact you can buy the identical products online for sometimes half the price. For instance, I recently saw a scooter with a RRP of £1495 for sale on the internet for £595 with the full warranty and delivery etc. I posed this to my local supplier and in an instant he had matched the price and guaranteed next day delivery with full assembly and testing. If they can afford to do this, why charge so much? Make less profit per item and sell 10 times the amount, especially with the economy they would have bulk buying.

    As for the Aldi or Lidl products, their quality if far superior to most of what is on sale elsewhere. They source their products from their home market Germany. to be able to sell safety or disability equipment in Germany, it must be TUV approved. This is far stricter than our British Standards Institute, and they hand out stiff fines for failures. That is why the German products have a 3 year warranty rather than our 12 month limited one. Far Superior and in my opinion exceptional value for money in ripoff Britain

    In short, supermarkets selling at wholesale prices has got to be better for everyone long term, as it will push the prices down everywhere
    ReplyDelete
  4. The reason the dealer dropped the price is because you asked him to match an unrealistic deal.

    It cant last forever as people will go out of business
    To to expect a local dealer with overheads and also experience and training to meet internet prices is ludicrous.
    I agree that some shops have overpriced equipment for years. But the public have to appreciate that you are also buying the security of the knowledge ,Service and training of the specialist shop.
    I can assure you that if you have problems with an internet bought scooter. Then you will have to return it back to base . If the company is based in blackpool and your in essex then expect £100 courier bill.
    Add to the fact that if the fault is not mechanical but user related then expect more on the bill.
    Supermarkets dont care about you ! if its not profitable in the long run they will delist items.

    Can you not realise that these are medical devices for people with problems. Not leisure vehicles for full abled people.
    Prices need to be sensible not extortionate. But
    As for pushing prices down
    ReplyDelete
  5. Supermarkets selling specialist products of this nature essentially means they are putting independent businesses who have staff with the experience and knowledge, out of business.
    Supermarkets have the power to get things at lower prices as their sole aim is to make money, do you think they will put as much effort into making sure their staff are efficiently knowledgable compared to making sure they maximise profits on a product? No they will not.

    Supermarkets selling at wholesale prices will not drive the prices down everywhere, they will put independent dealers out of business.

    And while a local supplier might price match to please his customers ( instead of complaining, you should be appreciating the fact he can offer this service ), he does not set the prices, in this day and age he has to price match to compete with internet retailers, who do not have the overheads that he will have.

    As for the scooter, there is no way someone could offer a scooter that cheap compared to another on the same profit margin, he would have had to have bought quite a lot to be able to sell it at such a low price and make money. Do you realise your local supplier could have only had the money to buy one or two? ( if your local supplier is an independent dealer with a shop, compared to an internet retailer, his overheads are way higher ), there is your answer as to why he probably can't lower the price as drastically as the other supplier could, and instead of complaining, you should be thanking him that he honoured such an extreme price match, as he probably lost money on that just so you would be happy.
    ReplyDelete
  6. I have to agree with the previous comments. A lot of these products require specialist advice before you're able to confidently buy the product that fits your needs. Supermarkets will now be able to use their bulk buying power to sell at the lowest price, driving the smaller mobility focused shops out of business, and its these shops that offer the quality of service that is absolutely necessary when buying these products. Supermarkets will drive the price down and potentially remove the much needed knowledge from local shops.

    However, at the moment I feel this is limited to a small range of products where the 'profit per area of shelf space' meets the required targets for supermarkets. A lot of mobility products will fall outside of this due to their size and weight. Hopefully the local stores can keep in business by still selling these products and providing the excellent customer service that the supermarkets can not, to keep customers coming back. I guess we shall soon see.
    ReplyDelete
  7. As a manufacturer and retailer I've recently been on the 'other side of the fence' when buying wheels to replace the worn ones on my Grandmother's wheelchair. You would think that replacements could be bought easily online, but I found the lack of detailed information on products astounding. This led in turn to us purchasing the right size wheels, but which subsequently had the wrong size axle. Despite the website promise of 'No quibble returns so you can buy in confidence' we have had endless problems, not to mention a highly unprofessional sales person, to contend with. Though they have collected the wheels, and we have forfeited 15% of the sale price as way of return postage, we still haven't had a refund. And mysteriously they are no longer answering our calls. I find myself thinking "if only there was a local shop we could have gone into, even if we'd paid slightly more we wouldn't have had this hassle (and wouldn't have paid return postage)" It worries me that it is far too easy to just start selling daily living aids, with no understanding of the user needs (or even care for the user needs?) which can only lead to a vote against supermarkets joining the ranks of faceless online sellers.
    ReplyDelete

Share your opinion - whether you agree or disagree, I'd love to hear from you!