15 September 2009

Care and Dishonesty - where have our morals gone?

I wonder whether you were as shocked as I was to hear about the latest research findings on the subject of dishonesty.

Our legal system - and indeed the functioning of our society in general - is based on the idea that reasonable and honest people share an understanding of what constitutes a dishonest act. So it is rather dispiriting to find that less than half of women, and even fewer men, think it is dishonest for a care home nurse to put pressure on an elderly patient to change their will in their favour. In fact, it was regarded as only marginally more dishonest than snapping the stalks off broccoli in the supermarket before weighing/paying. More than 80% of these same people think that
it IS dishonest to lie about your age on an internet dating site...

The fear of being frail and dependent is one that haunts many of us as we get older: thinking that a majority of the people you may be relying on for your day-to-day care believe that it's OK to manipulate you in this way is really scary.

Whatever happened to the caring and compassionate society that was supposed to come out of the global economic meltdown? It sounds more like "I'm all right, Jack, devil take the hindmost" - if I can mix my metaphors! Perhaps the people who responded to the survey will change their opinion when they are faced with choosing residential care for their own frail elderly parent (after all, it will then be their putative inheritance that is being redirected) or better yet, themselves.

Certainly, there is an increasing interest in services offering to vet or monitor carers on behalf of the client's family, reflecting the widespread suspicion that not all carers are as compassionate or as altruistic as we would like them to be.

What do you think? It feels as if every time you pick up a paper or turn on the radio there is another story about vulnerable people being let down or exploited in some way, yet at the same time we seem to be enmeshed in more and more legislation designed to prevent these things happening. While inspections involve being able to tick lots of boxes on a sheet, and most of us have such a shaky grasp of basic morality, it is perhaps not surprising that there is such a gap between the standards we allegedly aspire to and what is actually delivered.

4 comments:

  1. Regarding the Care & Dishonesty issue. As far as I am concerned it is 100% black & white particularly in regard to our sector where absolute trust in the way a person in care should be treated should be a given.

    Like you I find it very hard to accept less than 100% re this issue and would and should expect serious legal consequences for anyone taking advantage of their position.
    ReplyDelete
  2. Mike Spindle, TrekineticSep 16, 2009 03:17 AM
    I think the root of the problem is that Central Government Policy and no win, no fee lawyers are eroding the good in people.

    The high profile prison releases, supposedly on compassionate grounds, of people who have done or organised horrific crimes sends a message, that even if you go to prison the state will always care for and about you.

    Also, the constant hounding of good people either with speed cameras, or fear of losing their children, if they chastise them, everyone is becoming disillusioned and confused.

    What is the difference between right and wrong anyhow?

    With constant radio advertisements from no win, no fee Solicitors, everyone is being encouraged to lie and make exaggerated claims. Why not? Who can say whether a whiplash injury hurts in your sleep or not? You might as well lie and get enough money for a nice cruise round the Med.

    Also, young people are committing horrific crimes against old and defenseless people, but all we hear is how we are maintaining the human right of the criminal.

    It's about time that punishment for crime lived up to it's name and rehabilitation became the secondary consideration. Victims need to feel that the perpetrator will pay a price far higher than their loss, no far less.

    With no official difference between right and wrong, is it any wonder that the unscrupulous take advantage of whatever opportunity befalls them?
    ReplyDelete
  3. Although I agree with all that you say - I am not completely sure that the dishonesty is greater than the love and care which is given. The dishonesty as described is surely prevalent in this world, particularly where it relates to people who are more easily taken advantage of.

    However, unfortunate events which are so called "newsworthy" tend to be dishonest events, and we are constantly barraged by these, and we do not hear enough about the good ones.

    Certain areas of dishonesty need to be shown, so that we can eradicate their continued possibility, however I do feel that for every one dishonest event there are at least two honest ones.

    That is not to say that we should ignore the dishonest ones - I think that we should have the strength to eliminate them.
    ReplyDelete
  4. Excellent post and writing style. Bookmarked.
    ReplyDelete

Share your opinion - whether you agree or disagree, I'd love to hear from you!