The Office Of Fair Trading (OFT) has launched its investigation into the way that various mobility and daily living aids are sold. Their study will look at wheelchairs, scooters, stairlifts, bath aids, hoists, profiling beds and specialist seating.
Many of us have expressed concern over the years about some businesses operating in this area, and some dubious practices, from high-pressure selling techniques to exorbitant pricing, and equally concerning, companies with no experience of the special needs market selling specialist products to individuals without being able to give appropriate advice.
The OFT is concentrating on three main questions: can consumers access the right information so that they can purchase the right mobility aid for them; are suppliers treating consumers fairly; is competition in the wheelchair sector working well? These elements formed the bulk of responses to the organisation's consultation, with concern expressed that it is difficult to make an informed decision when purchasing a mobility aid, and that wheelchair sales in particular might not be as competitive as they should be, because of the structure of the market, and purchasing decisions made by public bodies.
Ann Pope, OFT Senior Director of Goods, said: "Mobility aids are important products for elderly and disabled people, which can significantly improve the quality of their lives. For many, they are an absolute necessity. Consultation with the industry, consumer groups and others has supported our initial view that there are consumer and competition issues in this sector that need examining to see if outcomes for consumers can be improved."
Independent Living has been operating for well over a decade now, providing impartial information to help people make the right choice of mobility aids. During this time, we have seen supermarkets, with no knowledge of how to assess a person's needs, stocking items like rollators, which need to be chosen with care. Equally, we have seen some Disabled Living Centres, which used to provide unbiased advice on a range of options, move into selling aids themselves, thereby removing a rare facility to try out different products without commercial pressures. We hear stories most weeks of individuals who have bought unsuitable products, either because they have come across a website which seems to be selling cheaply, or because an over-enthusiastic salesperson has persuaded them that they really need whatever it is he or she is trying to sell.
Good, caring service is available, from very many excellent suppliers – often, commercial organisations are doing a better job of giving impartial advice than the people you would expect to be giving it. Reputable companies would prefer not to make a sale than to sell something inappropriately: and in the long term, that attitude pays dividends, as consumers learn that they can trust you to have their interests at heart. But most people approach the buying of a mobility aid as complete novices; it is not, after all, something that is needed on a regular basis, unless you have a long-term disability, or are caring for someone in that situation. How does a newbie tell the difference between good, honest suppliers and the other sort? It isn't always easy, and sadly, membership of trade organisations doesn't always guarantee the highest standards, as a Which? investigation a few years ago demonstrated: the only company – out of the 11 investigated – which they ranked as "good", was not a member of the BHTA, whereas all those that received a ranking of just "OK", according to the BHTA's own code of conduct, were members…
The OFT report will be published in September, and we will certainly keep you up-to-date with its findings. Meanwhile, you can add your opinion and experiences to the debate, by commenting below!
Showing posts with label disabled living centre. Show all posts
Showing posts with label disabled living centre. Show all posts
21 February 2011
3 December 2009
DLCs - Impartial Advisers or Mobility Retailers?
It is now 10 years that the Independent Living website has been here, providing impartial information for carers and disabled or elderly individuals looking for equipment and services to help them manage more independently.
Perhaps not surprisingly, site visitors have sometimes confused us with the local organisations which are generally known as an Independent Living Centre or Disabled Living Centre. Given the similarity of the names, it is an understandable mistake, and to be honest, considering ourselves all to be in the same business of providing information without strings, we have not chafed at the confusion, and have often directed enquirers to their nearest DLC, as the place where they could try out a range of equipment without any commercial pressure.
Sadly, this fundamental fact about ILCs or DLCs is not a fact.
Depending on which centre you visit, you may indeed find that you can view a range of equipment, and perhaps try it out, or you may find that you are in a mobility retailer.
Without any apparent debate, it seems that a number of DLCs have turned themselves into shops. I find this difficult to understand on a number of levels. First, and most significantly, the entire raison d'ĂȘtre for an independent advice centre is to provide independent advice. As soon as the people giving the advice are also selling products, it is no longer independent. Individuals visiting a DLC are doing so almost always because they don't know the options available, and they should be able to expect a fair overview of the market, rather than a nudge towards whichever products the centre manager has for sale, regardless of their suitability.
However well-intentioned the staff at a centre where products are sold, they cannot possibly be fulfilling the brief to give impartial advice: they may well say that there is no pressure on people to buy, and that if the visitor is not happy with what they have for sale, they refer them to other stockists, but that is not the point. Inevitably, a person who is not familiar with mobility aids will be swayed by the selection that has already been made by the expert they are consulting. It may not even occur to them to ask about other possibilities.
My second concern is that Independent Living Centres often have charitable status - they are certainly all grouped under an umbrella organisation, Assist UK, which is a charity. I have written here before about charities that muddy the waters between themselves and commercial operators - Is Charity Just Another Big Business? - and I fear that this may be another example of enterprises that should be at one remove from commercial activities, getting involved regardless.
Having sought feedback across the network, the responses I have received underline the confusion. They range from what I would have thought defined an ILC:
"... in general all centres offer impartial advice so don't retail, all centres have a good range of equipment for people to try and most employ an occupational therapist." Swindon ILC
and "We do not sell anything, but our clients are given advice about how to proceed and also given information about manufacturers and retailers." The William Merritt Disabled Living Centre (Leeds)
To "a range of daily living and mobility aids for people to 'try and buy'....We are currently in the process of expanding our service, so much more will be available in the coming months." Inspire Community Trust, Kent
and "We do have some products in stock to sell, if not we are usually able to get them in with in 2 days." Disability Equipment Bradford
A look at the Disabled Living Foundation (the London DLC) website makes it absolutely clear that they don't sell any products, yet I understand that Manchester, one of the largest in the country, is well advanced with plans to integrate a retail and online shopping facility into their advice centre.
My researches suggest that perhaps twice as many don't sell as do; it is certainly not yet universal, and indeed there seems to be concern in some more traditional centres at the idea of getting involved in sales.
Surely this debate should have been conducted in an open fashion, rather than allowing commercialisation to creep up on what were centres of excellent, impartial advice, in a backdoor way. If you went to your local Citizens Advice Bureau, and they offered to sell you the services of a debt consolidation company, how would you feel? Would you still trust them to give you the best advice without commercial consideration, or would it seem that they had lost their special, trustworthy status?
There are many people working in this field who don't want Independent Living Centres turned into mobility shops - there are plenty of those around already. Despite the steps that have already been taken along this path, it isn't too late at least to ask the question, and challenge all those people involved to let us know why the ethos of DLCs has been changed in this way.
Do please add your comments to the discussion - just click the comment button, and if you prefer to remain anonymous, you can!
Perhaps not surprisingly, site visitors have sometimes confused us with the local organisations which are generally known as an Independent Living Centre or Disabled Living Centre. Given the similarity of the names, it is an understandable mistake, and to be honest, considering ourselves all to be in the same business of providing information without strings, we have not chafed at the confusion, and have often directed enquirers to their nearest DLC, as the place where they could try out a range of equipment without any commercial pressure.
Sadly, this fundamental fact about ILCs or DLCs is not a fact.
Depending on which centre you visit, you may indeed find that you can view a range of equipment, and perhaps try it out, or you may find that you are in a mobility retailer.
Without any apparent debate, it seems that a number of DLCs have turned themselves into shops. I find this difficult to understand on a number of levels. First, and most significantly, the entire raison d'ĂȘtre for an independent advice centre is to provide independent advice. As soon as the people giving the advice are also selling products, it is no longer independent. Individuals visiting a DLC are doing so almost always because they don't know the options available, and they should be able to expect a fair overview of the market, rather than a nudge towards whichever products the centre manager has for sale, regardless of their suitability.
However well-intentioned the staff at a centre where products are sold, they cannot possibly be fulfilling the brief to give impartial advice: they may well say that there is no pressure on people to buy, and that if the visitor is not happy with what they have for sale, they refer them to other stockists, but that is not the point. Inevitably, a person who is not familiar with mobility aids will be swayed by the selection that has already been made by the expert they are consulting. It may not even occur to them to ask about other possibilities.
My second concern is that Independent Living Centres often have charitable status - they are certainly all grouped under an umbrella organisation, Assist UK, which is a charity. I have written here before about charities that muddy the waters between themselves and commercial operators - Is Charity Just Another Big Business? - and I fear that this may be another example of enterprises that should be at one remove from commercial activities, getting involved regardless.
Having sought feedback across the network, the responses I have received underline the confusion. They range from what I would have thought defined an ILC:
"... in general all centres offer impartial advice so don't retail, all centres have a good range of equipment for people to try and most employ an occupational therapist." Swindon ILC
and "We do not sell anything, but our clients are given advice about how to proceed and also given information about manufacturers and retailers." The William Merritt Disabled Living Centre (Leeds)
To "a range of daily living and mobility aids for people to 'try and buy'....We are currently in the process of expanding our service, so much more will be available in the coming months." Inspire Community Trust, Kent
and "We do have some products in stock to sell, if not we are usually able to get them in with in 2 days." Disability Equipment Bradford
A look at the Disabled Living Foundation (the London DLC) website makes it absolutely clear that they don't sell any products, yet I understand that Manchester, one of the largest in the country, is well advanced with plans to integrate a retail and online shopping facility into their advice centre.
My researches suggest that perhaps twice as many don't sell as do; it is certainly not yet universal, and indeed there seems to be concern in some more traditional centres at the idea of getting involved in sales.
Surely this debate should have been conducted in an open fashion, rather than allowing commercialisation to creep up on what were centres of excellent, impartial advice, in a backdoor way. If you went to your local Citizens Advice Bureau, and they offered to sell you the services of a debt consolidation company, how would you feel? Would you still trust them to give you the best advice without commercial consideration, or would it seem that they had lost their special, trustworthy status?
There are many people working in this field who don't want Independent Living Centres turned into mobility shops - there are plenty of those around already. Despite the steps that have already been taken along this path, it isn't too late at least to ask the question, and challenge all those people involved to let us know why the ethos of DLCs has been changed in this way.
Do please add your comments to the discussion - just click the comment button, and if you prefer to remain anonymous, you can!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

